Easter has come and passed in a way that I would dare say few if any places of worship have ever before. Believers, those who want to believe, those who who aren’t sure but are willing to tab least hear, and those who come because someone they want to impress or love believe; one and all come to a place of worship and comfort. But not this year. This year the entire world was forced into a very unfamiliar and uncomfortable place that upon reflection see it as suspension between doubt and belief.
There is no doubt that we are living in increasingly uncertain times. Theres not a person I know who is untouched by strange words like COVID and Corona. I know of no one who is not aware of not-so-new but not-so-often used terms such as Social Distancing and Abundance of Caution. The fear and polarized filter that many hear these things only adds to the inability to mentally process never mind understand the severity of the very unstable pedestal upon which humanity currently stands. The pedestal of finance, education, social circles, commerce, government, and agriculture have all been very suddenly and universally exposed as very temporary and unreliable. I know of no-one who thought that any of these global systems humanity depended upon would be shaken by anything to this degree and even if it was imagined, the expected culprit was assumed “the other party” or a war… But not an unseeable virus.
Oh to be sure, people still believe that there is a way through this and know that troubles can’t last forever and that someday the sun will still rise. Theres a belief that the only variable is time which is at once comforting and anxiety inducing because time is not something we control but operate within. Most believe that there is someone who will swoop in wearing a red cape or tailored suit and save the day. Others believe that there is a bunker someplace that holds all of the answers that will put this all behind us. Still others believe and hope that this will all be just a uncomfortable memory that will be written about by authors, poets, and journalists for a while… and then quickly forgotten or dismissed as tabloid news.
I see the nervousness and general state of alarm ratcheting up all around and nothing people have traditionally gravitated to being able to offer the chance to exhale. The sense of being suspended in limbo is pervasive and leaves me sensing that humanity feels as if we are precariously hung between doubt and belief.
This is where Jesus was on Good Friday.
Jesus was crucified upon the symbol of death and example relied upon by the Roman Empire to assure control over dissenters and malefactors. The Roman society did not invent crucifixion but they did perfect it to horrific result. This form of extreme punishment was a very visible way of keeping people from trusting in anything other than them.
So when Pilate determined that Jesus had borne no fault or caused any break in that firm expectation of fealty one may understand why there was his willingness to seek refuge in involving his enemy Herod (Luke 23:12) so as not to bear this alone. When that failed, the chief priests were called into his circle. I say to you that I believe Pilate wanted to be released from his own place of suspension between belief in his government and doubt in the choice he was empowered to make, but dared not make.
But I ask you to consider that as precarious as Pilate and Herod and even the religious leaders of that time may have been, no one was more precariously hung than Jesus himself. Jesus was physically battered and emotionally spent. Worse yet, His own Father had forsaken Him. Notice I say He was forsaken but God did not leave Him. Over and over again we read through Isaiah, Psalms, Deuteronomy, Hebrews… God promised to never leave us or forsake his creation. Being abandoned and forsaken are two different things, however, and that should be explored at another time. For now please look at the physical place Jesus was in.
On that Friday, Jesus was fastened to a rough and rugged wooden cross in the most horrific way possible. But as God in corporeal flesh, he was not alone. Two men suffering a similar fate were with Him. One was a condemned malefactor, and the other a witness and believer in the sovereignty of Jesus. History suggests that Jesus was literally between the two. The malefactor assaulted Jesus with words that come from a place of doubt and disrespect saying “if” and “us”. His words suggest to my ears a demand that Jesus perform a miracle, but his expectation was a magic trick or a feat of might. He doubted not just the position of Christ as the Son of God, but also doubted His ability to save His own skin. That was one man known as a malefactor (Luke 23:39).
The other by my eyes was one who witnessed Jesus’ work, but was unchanged. I can imagine that there was on at least one occasion, the second who not only knew of Jesus works, and maybe had even witnessed His works. I can even imagine that he may have personally benefitted from the works of Jesus, and yet was not moved beyond committing crimes in the eyes of Rome. Or he could have held the misdirected anger that the Israelites did not get the political revolution they thought they’d get. Could it be that his crimes were such that the laws of Rome were unforgivable, but by Jesus, they are are? Recall that he admitted that they had committed crimes deserving of Romes life ending punishment. But he also knew that whatever they did that sealed their own fate, he had also seen enough to know that Jesus had not earned such a condemnation such as theirs. This reads to me as the a demonstration of true confession and repentance. Even in their last hours, Jesus heard this and something interesting happened. When Jesus was insistent on the hearers of His words paying attention he would repeat Himself; verily verily. But here He only said it once. This condemned man not only didn’t need further confirmation in the truth of who Jesus is, but he was in the end a believer who had no doubt.
My heart tells me that we too are witness to the works of Jesus and the only question is will we doubt Him or believe in Him? As we are suspended between to extremes, one filled with fear laced doubt and the other with repentant belief, we are called to choose one or the other. I believe that while we are in a global pandemic, afraid to go forward, and afraid to go back to what was, the choice to believe becomes all the more urgent. There is every reason to be wise and do as medical and public health officials ask of us. We can take that information and wisely apply their knowledge in our own lives if for no other reason because it will help protect our fellow community members. Yet in the end, the only real and final answer to the question of should I continue to waver between belief and doubt in The Way, The Truth, and The Life. Should I continue to only come to Jesus when I need a cosmic Santa Clause to give me something. Should I look for Jesus to perform some kind of act as evidence that He really is the Son of God? I would submit that the answer is no. We are to learn more about Him by studying His word. Strengthen our relationship with Him by talking with Jesus; prayer. Know that His works are not magic or self promotion but miraculous changes in the human condition and earthly state that all point directly to Him. I choose to steadily walk away from my frail human reaction to doubt, daily die to that mindset, and enter more deeply into belief.
Jesus did not stay suspended between doubt and belief – and neither will I.